Humility teaches us to put others first. Pride and ego manipulate us to put ourselves first.
When I moved to Scotland in 2011, I took a job as an engineering production manager on shift, working with the Scottish train operating company. My shift pattern was dayshift, backshift, and then nightshift. This was a rotating shift with 4 other team members doing the same role as I was.
The engineering depot I worked at was based in Edinburgh, and it was an extremely tough place to work. Most of the engineers were good to work with, but the leadership team were not.
The depot manager was a very aggressive person and led his teams through fear. This style of leadership then filtered down onto his managers who reported into him. So naturally, they led their teams in the same way.
At that time I thought I was supposed to lead in that way too, so I did for a while. However, I had been studying leadership for 2 years at this point, and I knew in my heart I was doing wrong.
DOWNLOAD MY FREE E-BOOK “INCREASE YOUR INFLUENCE”
But, my head was telling me that if I didn’t lead through fear, then I might lose my job. It was not a nice position to be in, and every day was becoming even more of a struggle.
After a while, I started to follow my heart and tried to lead the teams through influence. I didn’t want the teams to be in fear of me anymore. I tried to convince my teammates to do the same, but they were not willing to listen to me.
After all, I was a 28 year old inexperienced leader from Liverpool. Why would they listen or take advice from me? They had such massive egos that it would have been difficult for anyone to change their ways. I just focussed on myself and the teams I was leading when I was on shift.
My relationships with the teams started to strengthen, my influence was increasing and the teams were performing better. I even changed some of the processes within the leadership team, and my boss was really pleased with that, and gave me some praise.
This was a great moment for me, because I had changed my leadership style to one that I believed would work, and it was working. I believed in what I was doing so much, and was driven to make it happen.
However, after about 2 years of me working in Edinburgh the trains were not performing very well. We were getting a lot of customer complaints, and even made the evening news on more than one occasion. The blame for this was pointed to engineering.
The directors accused our depot of not maintaining the trains correctly, hence causing them to break down in service. When this happened this left a lot of passengers stranded at stations. It was not a good time for our depot.
2. Leadership Styles
The depot manager was “told” by the engineering director that someone had to be accountable. The engineering production management team were held accountable, and they then made me accountable. I was the newest member of the team, so it had to be me.
Even though I was changing processes and leadership styles. I was removed from the team and side stepped into a different role within the same depot.
But, I didn’t want to be part of that depot anymore. I was hurt by this move, and I wanted something different. So, I moved to Glasgow. I took a job as an engineering performance manager at the Glasgow railway depot. It was set up in the same way as the Edinburgh depot. But, it was different.
The depot manager was named Stuart. He was a tall, well-built person and actually looked like a leader. Before I even spoke to him, I could tell he was the depot manager.
He oozed confidence and charisma. When I spoke so some of the guys on the workshop floor, they all liked him. The engineering production managers liked him too. He wasn’t fearful, and didn’t lead through fear.
When I had my first conversation with Stuart, he asked me why I moved over to Glasgow and took up this role. I explained what had happened in Edinburgh, and he actually already knew. Although he had heard a few different stories from different people. This was all gossip, and I didn’t let it bother me.
Anyway, what I noticed most about Stuart in that initial conversation was how humble he was. He was the Glasgow depot manager, and had nearly 200 people in his charge. However, he was a team player. He constantly talked about “our team”, meaning the whole depot.
Following our conversation over the next few days I was in Stuart’s company quite a lot. I attended meetings that he chaired and walked the workshop floor with him.
He always stopped to chat with the teams, and not just about work either. Stuart is a huge football fan (soccer), as am I. So he talked about football, family, and how work was going. He modelled humility effortlessly.
If we are not humble with our teammates then we are not going to accomplish anything.
The depot manager in Edinburgh had too much pride to be humble. His ego was far too big, and that influenced the rest of his leadership team to be the same.
This had a negative impact on me and the whole depot. If you have too much pride, you are concerned with who is right. If you have humility, you are concerned with what is right.
Fortunately Stuart had a lot more humility than pride and he influenced his teams to be the same. He was one of the team. His influence was multiplied throughout the whole depot by his managers, team leaders, engineers, and the office teams. He focussed on doing the right thing, not on being right.
Stuart actually received the award of Leader of The Year throughout the whole of the Scottish Railways. So that was not just in engineering, it included all departments.
4. Team Player
To be a highly effective team player, you must be focussed on “WE” not “ME.” You need to put the team before yourself. That is what humility is all about.
Team players who have too much pride or ego are focussed on “ME” not “WE.” These team players are usually low performing and put themselves before anyone else.
A low performing team player with lots of pride and ego are oblivious to the damage and suffering they are causing within their team. They are so focussed on themselves that they don’t even care about their teammates.
When a team resolves around a low performing team player, they don’t accomplish a lot. They are held back by the flaws in the low performing team players character.
A low performing team player will actually look at someone who has humility as weak. Their ego makes them think that they are the strongest member of the team. It is in fact the total opposite.
They don’t realise that their influence decreases more and more as they continue behave in this way. They don’t know any other way, and therefore don’t know that they need to change.
A person with a lot of pride and ego are exposing themselves to the rest of us as being insecure. An insecure person does not have humility. They know within themselves that they are insecure, so they try to mask this insecurity by having an ego. The ego is not their true self, it is an act.
Highly effective team players do not need to mask who they really are. They are their true selves every day. They know who they are, and that is why they are highly effective.
DOWNLOAD MY FREE E-BOOK “INCREASE YOUR INFLUENCE”
They take pride in helping others, and giving the team credit for any achievements. They put the team before themselves. They will raise the team up before raising themselves.
Stuart is a highly effective leader, but he is also a highly effective team player. He put the team before himself, he helped them as much as he could.
He gave credit where it was due and never took any credit for himself. He spoke highly of his leadership team, his engineers, and his office teams. I am proud to call Stuart a friend.
If you are a humble person, then it shows that you have a strong character. We must constantly build our character. To have humility, you do not need to be in a leadership position or have a title. To have humility, you must put others first.
We must work hard every single day to be our true selves. This is not easy to do. I would rather be myself than have an ego and try to be somebody I’m not. I would rather be open with people and for them to be open with me. What would you rather do?
I welcome hearing how this post has influenced the way you think, the way you lead, or the results you have achieved because of what you’ve learned in it. Please feel free to share your thoughts with me by commenting below.
Check out my other articles by Clicking HERE
All the best,
10 thoughts on “What Is Humility?”
We like this article and we are going to share it with others, Humility is a big part of getting stronger when becoming a leader. Being a team can strengthen your skills and learning more ways being our true selves.
I appreciate you sharing your thoughts.
I am so pleased you are going to share this article with others, means the world to me.
All the best,
I bet that the team in Edinburgh constantly goes through new hiring processes. No one is going to last there a long time with a management that leads with fear. You made the right decision to go to Glasgow. A leader must have humility, not pride. Pride leads to downfall. I’m pretty sure that Stuart’s team consists of people who have stayed with the company for a long time and who are loyal to the company. A leader should inspire trust, not fear…
Thank you for sharing your comment, means a lot.
You are right, the team in Edinburgh so go through new hiring processes. They replace people far too quickly.
I couldn’t agree with you more, humility not pride.
All the best,
Ah, “leadership”. This article really resonated with me, Tom. Some people are born leaders; most are not. They need proper training in how to be effective leaders. And they frequently don’t get it.
“Leaders”/”Managers”, at least in my experience, are often people who’ve been promoted one step above their level of competency. They’re expected to get on with the job while no management training is provided (because that would cost the company money).
They’re often well aware of their own failings but try to cover their insecurities through bullying tactics and fear-led leadership, as you pointed out. And their insecurities prevent them from listening to other people.
I often felt like a “Cassandra” in the businesses I worked with. She’s the ancient Greek figure who uttered true prophecies but was never believed. I often told “Managers” what certain decisions and courses of action would lead to. They never listened because they thought they knew better. And when what I said would happen did happen, they all said no one told them this would happen.
They couldn’t get out of their own way – their enlarged egos prevented that.
The best manager I ever had was not a “Manager.” The “Manager” that had been hired to lead our software team decided he didn’t want the job, so one of the team was asked to take up the role. He knew what software guys needed and he worked as part of the team as well, not apart from it.
Under his leadership, our team was able to complete what was thought to be an impossible project and we brought it in ahead of schedule.
Our manager had no airs and graces, no oversized ego. He was just one of the guys, elevated to a role he did not expect. He treated everyone as equals and worked for the team as any much as any of the rest of us, That’s natural leadership and using your experience in the right way.
I finally gave up trying to convince “Managers” what the best ways of doing things were and I threw in the towel as a professional programmer in 2004. Been a full-time affiliate marketer ever since and haven’t missed, for a single minute, the influence of a crappy, unhumble “Manager” 🙂
All the best,
Nobody is born a leader, but everybody is born with the ability to influence another person. Therefore, everybody is born with the ability to lead.
I appreciate you sharing a very detailed comment with your own experiences in it.
I hope the people who read this article will be able to relate to your comment and learn just as much from you as they do from me.
Keep working on your humility and being humble with your people.
All the best,
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on humility. I completely agree that humility is an important trait for leaders to possess. It allows them to be open to learning and growth, and to recognize and value the contributions of others. As you pointed out from your experience when you worked in Edinburgh, its good to know that one shouldn’t lead people with fear. In fact, leading in humility helps to create a positive and inclusive culture within an organization. I think your suggestion to practice humility actively is also an important one. By continuously working on being humble, leaders can ensure that it becomes a core part of their leadership style. Keep up the good work!
I appreciate your comment.
Keep working on being humble with your people and leading them by example. This is the most important leadership principle and is the best way to inspire your people to follow you.
All the best,
I’ve noticed, in my time being in several corporations, and now a small business – that many people in leaderships roles rarely have humility. They often look down on others that don’t fit in their specific criteria, no matter what job it is.
In the retail world, managers come in a variety of styles. Meaning, some – though not many – value their employees and look forward to those conversations where they can get the constructive criticism they need to grow along with their team.
Then, you have the opposite spectrum – those that think only their way is the best way, no matter anyone else’s time on the job, years of experience, both presently and past. I’ve worked with this style more than the true leaders out there.
Conversations with this type of management is always hard, especially when you’re trying to help your team to grow, or do better. Opinions for growth are often met with, “No, that simply won’t work. Do this for sales.”
It’s often those managers that cause employees to leave, thus creating a high turn-over rate, and a constant uphill battle to succeed in an annual increase in sales to stay open and trending with the current market.
It’s too bad when people just can’t get out of their own way in order to be successful in the grand scheme of things.
Thanks for sharing your insights! Love them!
Thank you for sharing your comment and for adding so much detail, I really apreciate it.
There will be a lot of people who read this who will be able to relate to you, and the retail world of management/leadership. I hope they can learn from you just as much as they can from me.
Thank you again for sharing such experiences and I am pleased that you found value in my article.
All the best,